Should You Accept Your Payment Provider’s Retention Offer?
Compare a renewal or retention deal with switching, including exit costs, introductory discounts and any new contract commitment.
The short answer
A retention offer is worth considering when its complete cost and service terms beat the realistic alternatives. Compare staying unchanged, accepting the offer and switching over the same period. Confirm whether accepting a discount restarts a minimum term, changes other prices or creates conditions for keeping an incentive.
In this guide
What is a payment provider retention offer?
A retention offer is an improvement proposed to keep your business, often after a pricing review or a conversation about leaving. It might reduce processing rates, change equipment rental, provide a temporary credit or alter service terms. None of those features establishes the overall saving on its own.
Record the exact offer and its expiry date. A verbal promise of a matched rate is incomplete if the alternative also has different fixed charges or card eligibility. Ask for the complete revised agreement before accepting.
Build a three-option comparison
| Option | What to include |
|---|---|
| Stay unchanged | Current rates, ongoing fees and any confirmed future price changes. |
| Accept retention offer | Revised rates, retained services, change fees, credit conditions and the new commitment. |
| Switch provider | Alternative running costs, old-supplier liability, setup, overlap and replacement equipment. |
Calculate the first year and a period long enough to reveal the commitments you are comparing. If a temporary discount ends after three months, use three discounted months and nine normal months, not twelve discounted months. Make any assumptions about prices after a fixed period explicit.
Worked example: the cheapest monthly price is not the cheapest first year
Fictional offers with equivalent required functions. Assume prices and trading stay constant for the comparison period.
| Option | Monthly running cost | One-off cost | First-year total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stay unchanged | £300 | £0 | £3,600 |
| Accept retention offer | £250 | £0 | £3,000 |
| Switch | £230 | £600 | £3,360 |
Retention saves £600 against doing nothing in year one. Switching saves £240 against doing nothing, but costs £360 more than accepting retention. Switching then has a £20 monthly running-cost advantage over retention, so its £600 upfront cost takes 30 months to recover on those unchanged assumptions.
That break-even does not settle the decision if either price expires earlier or service differs. Extend the comparison only with stated assumptions.
Check the conditions behind the improvement
- Does a fresh minimum term begin, and which agreements does it affect?
- Is the reduction permanent, time-limited or conditional on turnover?
- Are all relevant card groups covered?
- Can scheme costs or other charges still change?
- Must you return an incentive if you leave, downgrade or close?
- Does the offer change equipment ownership, replacement support or integration costs?
If a supplier contributes towards exit fees, record when reimbursement happens and what evidence is required. Keep the old supplier’s confirmed liability in your cash budget until the contribution is actually available.
A clear response to a retention offer
Thank you for the revised offer. Before I decide, please confirm the full fee schedule, effective date, minimum term and cancellation provisions. Please also confirm which prices can change, the duration of any discount and all conditions attached to credits or equipment. I will compare the written offer using the same trading figures as the alternative.
Use the calculator for the cost comparison and keep the contractual questions alongside it. A favourable number does not confirm compatibility or acceptance terms. For an earlier-stage conversation, use our negotiation template.
Common questions
Does accepting a lower rate automatically renew my contract?
Not necessarily. The effect depends on the terms of the specific offer. Ask for explicit written confirmation before accepting.
Should I always let the existing provider match a quote?
It can be useful to invite a response, but compare service and contractual conditions as well as price. A rate match is not necessarily a match of total costs.
Put your own figures to work.
Use the free calculator to organise your costs and keep a report. If something is unclear, you can ask for a free initial review.
No registration required. Calculator entries stay in your open browser page unless you choose to share a report in a review request.
Sources and how to use this guide
Primary references checked on 15 October 2026:
- PSR: card-acquiring market remedies and comparison information
- PSR: Specific Direction 16 and consolidated May 2024 text
Worked examples are original fictional scenarios, not customer results, market averages or provider quotations. Unless stated otherwise, they use a consistent VAT basis and include only the costs listed. Provider prices, eligibility and terms can change. Check your written agreement before deciding.
Our guides explain costs and comparison methods. They do not rank the whole market or claim hands-on product testing. Source links are references, not a claim of partnership. Read the calculation method and limitations, or about the service.